Williamsa III i Micka Graya (DC/Wildstorm/ABC) 2002: #22 Daniela Clowesa (Fanthagraphic) 2003: The Stuff of Dreams Kima Deitcha (Fanthagraphic) 2004: Podwójna nagroda dla Conan the Legend #0 Kurta Busieka i Cary’ego Norda oraz Zbir #1 Erica Powella (Obydwa z wydawnictwa Dark Horse) 2005: Eightball #23 Daniela Clowesa (Fanthagraphic) 2006: Solo #5 Darwyna Cooke’a (DC) 2007: Batman/the Spirit Jepha Loeba i Darwyna Cooke’a (DC) 2008: Justice League of America #11 Brada Meltzera i Gene’a Ha (DC) 2009: nagrody nie przyznano 2010: Kapitan Ameryka #601 Eda Brubakera i Gene’a Colana (Marvel) 2011: Hellboy: Double Feature of Evil Mike’a Mignoli i Richarda Corbena (Dark Horse) 2012: Daredevil #7 Marka Waida, Paolo Rivery i Joego Rivery (Marvel) 2013: The Mire Becky Cloonan (wydana samodzielnie) 2014: Hawkeye #11 Matta Fractiona i Davida Aja (Marvel) 2015: Beasts of Burden: Hunters and Gatherers Evana Dorkina i Jill Thompson (Dark Horse) 2016: Silver Surfer #11 Dana Scotta i Michaela Allreda (Marvel) 2017: Beasts of Burden: What the Cat Dragged In Evana Dorkina, Sary Dyer i Jill Thompsob (Dark Horse) 2018: Hellboy: Krampusnacht Mike’a Mignoli i Adama Hughesa (Dark Horse) 2019: Peter Parker: The Spectacular Spider-Man #310 Chipa Zdarsky’ego (Marvel) 2020: Our Favorite Thing Is My Favorite Thing Is Monsters Emila Ferrisa