Nagrody 2005 NagrodaKategoriaTeen Choice AwardsChoice Reality/Variety Star – FemaleBillboard Music AwardsTop-Selling Hot 100 Song of the Year: "Inside Your Heaven"Top-Selling Country Single: "Inside Your Heaven"Country Single Sales Artist of the Year
2006 NagrodaKategoriaGospel Music Association AwardsCountry Recorded Song of the Year: "Jesus, Take the Wheel"CMT Music AwardsFemale Video Of The Year: "Jesus, Take the Wheel"Breakthrough Video of the Year: "Jesus, Take the Wheel"Academy of Country Music AwardsTop New Female Vocalist of the YearSingle Record of the Year: "Jesus, Take the Wheel"NARP Organization of Record Retail MerchantsBreakthrough Country ArtistMusic RowCritics PickCountry Music Association AwardsFemale Vocalist of the YearHorizon Award12th Annual Inspirational Country Music AwardsMainstream Country Artist of the YearAmerican Music AwardsFavorite New Breakthrough ArtistBillboard Music AwardsFemale Country Artist of the YearAlbum of the YearCountry Album of the YearCountry New Artist of the YearFemale Billboard 200 Album Artist of the YearCanadian Country Music AwardsSOCAN Song of the Year: "Jesus, Take the Wheel"