Nagrody 2005 – Melbourne International Comedy Festival – Directors' za „Choice za „Dark Side” 2005 – Edinburgh Festival Fringe Perrier – Comedy Award, Best Newcomer 2005 – Melbourne International Comedy Festival – The Groggy Squirrel Critics’ Award 2007 – U.S. Comedy Arts Festival – Best Alternative Act 2009 – Helpmann Award for Best Comedy Performer - za „Ready For This?” 2009 – Green Room Awards – Cabaret: Best Original Songs 2009 – Green Room Awards – Cabaret: Best Artiste 2010 – Chortle Awards – Best Music or Variety Act 2011 – Helpmann Award for Best New Australian Work – dla Tim Minchin Vs Sydney Symphony 2012 – Olivier Awards – Best New Musical za „Matilda The Musical” 2012 – Helpmann Award for Best Comedy Performer – za „Tim Minchin vs The Orchestras Round II” 2013 – What’s On Stage Awards, The W&P Longreach Best Supporting Actor – za „Jesus Christ Superstar” 2016 – Logie Award, Most Outstanding Supporting Actor – za „The Secret River„ 2016 – Helpmann Award for Best Original Score – za „Matilda the Musical” 2017 – Olivier Awards – Best New