Sherm Lollar Bobby Shantz 1958 Vic Power Frank Bolling Frank Malzone Luis Aparicio # Norm Siebern Al Kaline # Jimmy Piersall Sherm Lollar Bobby Shantz 1959 Vic Power Nellie Fox # Frank Malzone Luis Aparicio # Jackie Jensen Al Kaline # Minnie Miñoso Sherm Lollar Bobby Shantz 1960 Vic Power Nellie Fox # Brooks Robinson * # Luis Aparicio # Jim Landis Roger Maris Minnie Miñoso Earl Battey 1961 Vic Power Bobby Richardson Brooks Robinson * # Luis Aparicio # Jim Landis Al Kaline # Jimmy Piersall Earl Battey Frank Lary 1962 Vic Power Bobby Richardson Brooks Robinson * # Luis Aparicio # Jim Landis Al Kaline # Mickey Mantle # Earl Battey Jim Kaat 1963 Vic Power Bobby Richardson Brooks Robinson * # Zoilo Versalles Jim Landis Al Kaline # Carl Yastrzemski # Elston Howard Jim Kaat 1964 Vic Power Bobby Richardson Brooks Robinson * # Luis Aparicio # Jim Landis Al Kaline # Vic Davalillo Elston Howard Jim Kaat 1965 Joe Pepitone Bobby Richardson Brooks Robinson * # Zoilo Versalles Tom Tresh Al Kaline # Carl Yastrzemski # Bill Freehan Jim Kaat 1966 Joe Pepitone Bobby Knoop Brooks Robinson * # Luis Aparicio # Tommie Agee Al Kaline # Tony Oliva Bill Freehan Jim Kaat 1967 George Scott Bobby Knoop Brooks Robinson * # Jim Fregosi Paul Blair Al Kaline # Carl Yastrzemski # Bill Freehan Jim Kaat 1968 George Scott Bobby Knoop Brooks Robinson * # Luis