# Iván Rodríguez * Mike Mussina 1999 Rafael Palmeiro Roberto Alomar * # Scott Brosius Omar Vizquel Bernie Williams Shawn Green Ken Griffey Jr. # Iván Rodríguez * Mike Mussina 2000 John Olerud Roberto Alomar * # Travis Fryman Omar Vizquel Bernie Williams Jermaine Dye Darin Erstad Iván Rodríguez * Kenny Rogers 2001 Doug Mientkiewicz Roberto Alomar * # Eric Chavez Omar Vizquel Torii Hunter Mike Cameron Ichiro Suzuki Iván Rodríguez * Mike Mussina 2002 John Olerud Bret Boone Eric Chavez Alex Rodriguez Torii Hunter Darin Erstad Ichiro Suzuki Belgie Molina Kenny Rogers 2003 John Olerud Bret Boone Eric Chavez Alex Rodriguez Torii Hunter Mike Cameron Ichiro Suzuki Belgie Molina Mike Mussina 2004 Darin Erstad Bret Boone Eric Chavez Derek Jeter Torii Hunter Vernon Wells Ichiro Suzuki Iván Rodríguez * Kenny Rogers 2005 Mark Teixeira Orlando Hudson Eric Chavez Derek Jeter Torii Hunter Vernon Wells Ichiro Suzuki Jason Varitek Kenny Rogers 2006 Mark Teixeira Mark Grudzielanek Eric Chavez Derek Jeter Torii Hunter Vernon Wells Ichiro Suzuki Iván Rodríguez * Kenny Rogers 2007 Kevin Youkilis Plácido Polanco Adrián Beltré Orlando Cabrera Torii Hunter Grady Sizemore Ichiro Suzuki Iván Rodríguez * Johan Santana 2008 Carlos Peña Dustin Pedroia Adrián Beltré Michael Young Torii Hunter Grady Sizemore Ichiro Suzuki Joe Mauer Mike Mussina 2009 Mark