Leary 1989 Will Clark Ryne Sandberg * # Howard Johnson Barry Larkin * # Kevin Mitchell Tony Gwynn # Eric Davis Craig Biggio # Don Robinson 1990 Eddie Murray # Ryne Sandberg * # Matt Williams Barry Larkin * # Barry Bonds * Bobby Bonilla Darryl Strawberry Benito Santiago Don Robinson 1991 Will Clark Ryne Sandberg * # Howard Johnson Barry Larkin * # Barry Bonds * Bobby Bonilla Ron Gant Benito Santiago Tom Glavine # 1992 Fred McGriff Ryne Sandberg * # Gary Sheffield Barry Larkin * # Barry Bonds * Larry Walker Andy Van Slyke Darren Daulton Dwight Gooden 1993 Fred McGriff Robby Thompson Matt Williams Jay Bell Barry Bonds * Lenny Dykstra David Justice Mike Piazza * # Orel Hershiser 1994 Jeff Bagwell Craig Biggio # Matt Williams Wil Cordero Barry Bonds * Tony Gwynn # Moisés Alou Mike Piazza * # Mark Portugal 1995 Eric Karros Craig Biggio # Vinny Castilla Barry Larkin * # Sammy Sosa Tony Gwynn # Dante Bichette Mike Piazza * # Tom Glavine # 1996 Andrés Galarraga Eric Young Ken Caminiti Barry Larkin * # Barry Bonds * Gary Sheffield Ellis Burks Mike Piazza * # Tom Glavine # 1997 Jeff Bagwell Craig Biggio # Vinny Castilla Jeff Blauser Barry Bonds * Tony Gwynn # Larry Walker Mike Piazza * # John Smoltz # 1998 Mark McGwire Craig Biggio # Vinny Castilla Barry Larkin * # Sammy Sosa Greg Vaughn Moisés Alou Mike Piazza * # Tom Glavine # 1999 Jeff