Styles (TNA)2004Chris Benoit (WWE)Randy Orton (WWE)Eddie Guerrero (WWE)AJ Styles (TNA)2005Batista (WWE)John Cena (WWE)AJ Styles (TNA)Samoa Joe (TNA)2006John Cena (WWE)Samoa Joe (TNA)Rey Mysterio (WWE)Edge (WWE)2007John Cena (WWE)Kurt Angle (TNA)Batista (WWE)Randy Orton (WWE)2008Triple H (WWE)Kurt Angle (TNA)Randy Orton (WWE)Samoa Joe (TNA)2009Randy Orton (WWE)John Cena (WWE)Chris Jericho (WWE)Kurt Angle (TNA)2010Randy Orton (WWE)Rob Van Dam (TNA)John Cena (WWE)Sheamus (WWE)2011CM Punk (WWE)John Cena (WWE)Davey Richards (ROH)Bobby Roode (TNA)2012CM Punk (WWE)Sheamus (WWE)Austin Aries (TNA)John Cena (WWE)2013Daniel Bryan (WWE)John Cena (WWE)Bully Ray (TNA)Randy Orton (WWE)2014Brock Lesnar (WWE)Daniel Bryan (WWE)AJ Styles (NJPW, ROH)John Cena (WWE)2015Seth Rollins (WWE)Jay Lethal (ROH)Roman Reigns (WWE)John Cena (WWE)2016AJ Styles (WWE)Roman Reigns (WWE)Kevin Owens (WWE)Dean Ambrose (WWE)2017AJ Styles (WWE)Kazuchika Okada (NJPW)Kenny Omega (NJPW)Cody (NJPW)2018AJ Styles (WWE)Kenny Omega (NJPW)Cody (NJPW)Seth Rollins (WWE)2019Adam Cole (WWE)Chris Jericho (AEW)Seth Rollins (WWE)Kofi Kingston (WWE)2020Jon Moxley (AEW)Bayley (WWE)Chris Jericho (AEW)Sasha Banks (WWE)2021Kenny Omega (AEW)Roman Reigns (WWE)Bianca Belair (WWE)Big E (WWE)2022Roman Reigns (WWE)Jon Moxley (AEW)Cody Rhodes (WWE)Bianca Belair (WWE)2023Seth Rollins (WWE)Gunther