Hill"b/w "The Touch of God’s Hand" | — | — |- | scope="row" | "My Everything"b/w "Second Fling" | 7 | — | align="left" rowspan="2"|utwory spoza albumu |- | scope="row" | "Hep Cat Baby"b/w "This Is the Thanks I Get (For Loving You)" (z albumu One More Time) | 7 | — |- | scope="row" | "Christmas Can’t Be Far Away"b/w "I’m Your Private Santa Claus" (utwór spoza albumu) | — | — | align="left"| Christmas with Eddy Arnold|- | rowspan="7"| 1955 | scope="row" | "I've Been Thinking"b/w "Don't Forget" | 2 | — | align="left" rowspan="3"|utwory spoza albumu |- | scope="row" | "I Always Have Someone to Turn To"b/w "It Took a Miracle" (z albumu The Chapel on the Hill) | — | — |- | scope="row" | "In Time"b/w "Two Kinds of Love" | 6 | — |- | scope="row" | "The Cattle Call"b/w "The Kentuckian Song" (z albumu One More Time) | 1 | 69 | align="left"| Cattle Call|- | scope="row" | "That Do Make It Nice"b/w "Just Call Me Lonesome" | 1 | — | align="left" rowspan="2"|One More Time|- | scope="row" | "The Richest Man (In the World)"b/w "I Walked Alone Last Night" (utwór spoza albumu) | 10 | 99 |- | scope="row" | "Trouble in Mind"b/w "When You Said Goodbye" | 6 | — | align="left"|utwory spoza albumu |- | rowspan="5"| 1956 | scope="row" | "Bayou Baby"b/w "Do You Know Where God Lives?" (utwór spoza albumu) | — | — | align="left"| When They Were Young|- |