scope="row" | "You Don’t Know Me"<small>b/w "The Rockin’ Mockin' Bird" (z albumu I’m Throwing Rice' and Other Favorites)</small> | 10 | — | align="left"|Eddy Arnold Sings Them Again|- | scope="row" | "Casey Jones (The Brave Engineer)"b/w "You Were Mine for Awhile" (utwór spoza albumu) | 15 | — | align="left"| I’m Throwing Rice' and Other Favorites|- | scope="row" | "I Wouldn't Know Where to Begin"b/w "The Ballad of Wes Tancred" | — | 22 | align="left" rowspan="2"|utwory spoza albumu |- | scope="row" | "A Dozen Hearts"b/w "A Good Lookin' Blonde" | — | — |- | rowspan="4"| 1957 | scope="row" | "Gonna Find Me a Bluebird"b/w "Little Bit" (z albumu More Eddy Arnold) | 12 | 51 | align="left"| I’m Throwing Rice' and Other Favorites|- | scope="row" | "Open Your Heart"b/w "Crazy Dream" | — | — | align="left"|utwory spoza albumu |- | scope="row" | "When He Was Young"b/w "Little Miss Sunbeam" (utwór spoza albumu) | — | — | align="left"| When They Were Young|- | scope="row" | "Wagon Wheels"b/w "You've Made Up for Everything" (utwór spoza albumu) | — | — | align="left" rowspan="2"| I’m Throwing Rice' and Other Favorites|- | rowspan="4"| 1958 | scope="row" | "Too Soon to Know"b/w "I Need Somebody" (z albumu